Monday, June 23, 2008

Alabama Judicial System Gets a D+ in Judicial Ethics

They really should have gotten an F- in judicial ethics. Case and point.


ERIC VELASCO
News staff writer
Birmingham News

Alabama's system of enforcing judicial ethics received poor marks in a report card recently issued by the national watchdog group HALT.

HALT, or Help Abolish Legal Tyranny, gave Alabama an overall grade of D+ and ranked the state 38th in its 2008 Judicial Accountability Report Card.

The Washington-based legal reform group issued failing grades for not requiring judges to publicly disclose potential financial conflicts and for putting few limits on receiving gifts.

HALT said the report was the first comprehensive nationwide study of systems used by states to police judicial ethics. Alabama was one of 16 state and federal jurisdictions with overall grades below C.

The survey said the procedures and investigations by the Alabama Judicial Inquiry Commission are not transparent enough, and the system lacks meaningful sanctions.

"Alabama's system of judicial oversight gives too many judges a free pass," Suzanne M. Blonder, HALT's senior counsel, said in a statement. "We hope that Alabama's chief judicial officers will work to transform a mechanism marred by secrecy into a system dedicated to upholding the integrity of the judiciary."

Jenny Garrett, executive director of the Alabama Judicial Inquiry Commission, said she strongly disagreed with HALT's assessments and Blonder's comments.

"Alabama has always been considered to be in the forefront of judicial ethics," she said. "This commission is very diligent in following the rules of procedures promulgated by the Alabama Supreme Court and the state Constitution."

The commission, however, believes some of the rules it must follow have hurt the system's integrity, Garrett said.

Under the leadership of then-Chief Justice Roy Moore, the state's high court changed rules in 2001, allowing accused judges to receive copies of complaints against them. The information included the name of the person who filed the complaint.

"Our filings of complaints dropped in half," Garrett said. The most drastic drop was in complaints by lawyers, she said.

A court committee is now considering restoring complainant confidentiality.

Alabama's Judicial Inquiry Commission receives and investigates complaints filed against judges and justices, and recommends whether formal charges should be filed.
v
Those charges are considered by a nine-member Court of the Judiciary, which can suspend, remove or otherwise censure a judge.

One of the court's best-known decisions was when it ousted Moore as chief justice in 2003 for defying a federal judge's order to remove his Ten Commandments monument from the Supreme Court building in Montgomery.

Praise, criticism:

HALT gave Alabama a high mark for what the group called "consumer friendliness" because the state does not ban people from speaking publicly about complaints they file against judges.

But HALT criticized the Judicial Inquiry Commission because its Web site does not have complaint forms to download.

Garrett agreed a downloadable form was needed, and said a Web site update is in the works. She said all information a complainant needs to know is listed online, mostly in the commission's annual reports.

Other issues cited by HALT include the fact that the commission does not release information about complaints until it files formal charges.
-------------


HALT gave Alabama a high mark for what the group called "consumer friendliness" because the state does not ban people from speaking publicly about complaints they file against judges.

Huh? In the letter the Judicial Inquiry Commission sent me reporting that they had taken appropriate action against Judge Kim Taylor they forbade me from discussing it saying it was confidential information. I completely ignored their rules on that one. If a judge does wrong and gets sanctioned for it and it is a case that involves me then you can bet you ass that I'm a tell it!! I'm a tell it all!!

Here is another way that the judicial inquiry commission sucks....they refuse to tell you what action they took against a judge. I feel if I file a complaint and it is acted upon in my favor then I have a right to know what action was taken. How come the judge, who is obviously guilty of wrong doing gets to hide behind this cloak of secrecy? If we regular citizens get caught doing something wrong and are subsequently convicted of it our punishments are broadcast all over the media and our communities. It should be no different for those whose task it is to 'judge us'.





del.icio.us
Google
Yahoo

11 comments:

Anonymous said...

there is a judge in chambers county alabama who shows big favors to drug users and dope cookers because their dad remodeled his house. who can talk to about it? there are small kids involved..

Anonymous said...

someone needs to investigate Judge George Brown in mobile,al.....this judge discrimiates against women..and gives our children to abuvise men....

Anonymous said...

I agree Judge George Brown in Mobile,Al gives children to Abuvise me and this Judge needs to be investigated. but who will take the time to do this.unless it is your child most people do not care.we have called The DA but its not in his department so what do you do....

Anonymous said...

I agree Judge George Brown in Mobile, AL should be investigated. I have been told by attorney's, that the reason he is for the father, is due to what his ex-wife did to him, this should be about the child not hard feelings towards women.

boshi said...

sparkly unicorns, to glow-in-the-dark dolphins, these new fashion rubber bands
silly bandz have everyone talking. With the thousands of different varieties to choose from,

children and young adults have found it easy to grab onto this new fad. Plus, the price is right --the average price for a theme pack of 24 is around $4. Most of us

think, “Oh! What a steal; that’s such a great price.” When the reality of it is, the cost of 24 regular rubber bands is less than $1. Why pay more for shaped rubber

bands, when you can have regular ones for cheaper?

Cindy said...

Judge George Brown of Mobile Al.
Is a evil man.He takes childen from good Mothers and give's them to ABUVISM men.It is called legal
kidnapping.I know. I'm one of those
Mothers.Missing my baby girl.

Cindy Rupe said...

I really don't understand this George Brown's reasoning.I am a stay at home mother to a two year old little girl.I don't smoke,drink,party,or do drugs.I am married and I own my own home.My daughters father was convicted of domestic violence against me that occurred when I was three months pregnant with her.My daughters father asked for custody of her whenever she was a year old.He never attempted to know her.They granted him custody of my little girl after a forty five minute trail and without the judge or the guardian ad litem ever seeing her.The judges only explanation for this was said to my lawyer in his chamber and it was "your client lost".That was all he had to say for putting my child,myself,and my family through hell.Someone needs to do something to get this judge put in jail where he belongs.

Penis Enlargement Pills said...

I recently came across your blog and have been reading along. I think I will leave my first comment.
I don’t know what to say except that I have enjoyed reading. Nice blog.
I will keep visiting this blog very often.
By the way,
Blogger how when you visit my blog,
My Blog have been created for the satisfaction of consumer of all.
by http://www.factspenisenlargement.com

Penis Enlargement Pills said...

I recently came across your blog and have been reading along. I think I will leave my first comment.
I don’t know what to say except that I have enjoyed reading. Nice blog.
I will keep visiting this blog very often.
By the way,
Blogger how when you visit my blog,
My Blog have been created for the satisfaction of consumer of all.
by http://www.factspenisenlargement.com

viagra online said...

I wanted you to know that I always pay much attention to the literary style on each blogger and that is one of the reasons why I like yours so much, cause you can write without any pretension and that makes the entry so fresh and easy to read, though its very clear judicial inclination.

youtube to mp3 converter free said...

Multiple sorts of youtube converter are boundless before constant arrive with cost-free trial versions.